46 Comments

This post simplified how risk and return work together and how investing is achievable for everyone, whether they are risk-averse or not. Explaining low-index funds made investing feel more doable and approachable for people newly entering the stock market. It pointed out that people don’t need investment management in order to be successful and that personal insight will go further than the charts shown on the news.

Expand full comment

As someone who is personally somewhat risk-tolerant, I find this article incredibly insightful. While I may have made certain choices in the past, this article has the information I needed to stay on the right path. I also find this information very important for people to understand. Saving and investing early can set you on a path to success in the future. Understanding these accounts can also prove to make your future easier as you develop your knowledge.

Expand full comment

This article does a great job of breaking down personal finance and investing into simple steps. It advises to avoid expensive investment advice and instead stick to low-cost index funds, which have been proven to work well over time. Teaching students about saving and investing early is important since most people will deal with retirement accounts or other investments down the road. Tools like FINRA’s risk-return game help people understand how investments work and what to expect, making it easier to navigate investments with confidence.

Expand full comment

I completely agree with the not paying for investment advice. Obviously a Bloomberg

,Barrons, WSJ, and etc subscription is necessary, but too much in this day and age will people offer, courses or stock picks for a fee and it is all a scam. I time and time again find myself asking why would one buy it, and then come to the conclusion they do not have the proper financial education.

Expand full comment

Appreciate you sharing you takeaway, Tom.

Expand full comment

What are some specific examples of index funds that beginners might consider, and how can someone decide which ones align best with their financial goals?

Expand full comment

I think the focus on index funds as a low-cost, practical option makes investing more accessible to everyone. Since most households rely on retirement plans I see index funds as a simpler solution. It also reinforces the importance of understanding basic concepts like risk and return, no matter your level of experience.

Expand full comment

You emphasize avoiding active investment management in favor of index funds. Are there any specific scenarios where active management might still be a better option?

Expand full comment

Some people value handing off investment decisions to a financial advisor. I am fine with that if a) the adviser doesn't charge an assets under management fee (AUM) greater than 0.10% and b) the portfolio is very broadly diversified.

Expand full comment

I really like how the article makes the idea of managing our money a bit more simple, which helps put things into a better perspective. I think that the game did a great job in not only having you think about what was correct, but also explained the effects, such as when discussing high vs low risk investments. I thought that the graphs that showed the proportion of the population not investing in retirement-investments was a great piece of evidence to add because it helps us see that there are other investments that we can include in our lives, which then allow us to diversify and mitigate the risk that comes with it. I'm glad that these articles are straight to the point as well because it helps me fully understand what is being said and gives me a better idea when I'm lost.

Expand full comment

One of my favorite aspects of the game was that it really does represent situations that most of us will encounter in our lives, which makes it very realistic. I also agree with another comment that I saw, which highlights the importance of planning ahead and for your and maybe your family’s future instead of planning in the moment or for the very short future. I also really appreciate how you make the information on risk versus return very digestible and easy to understand and work through with the game. I think that takes away a lot of the scary thoughts surrounding stocks or financial planning in general.

Expand full comment

Appreciate you letting me know the right chord was hit.

Expand full comment

I like how the article simplifies the idea of managing money, making it feel approachable for everyone. For instance, it highlights the benefits of low-cost index funds, showing that smart investing doesn’t have to be expensive. In other words, the article makes investing seem more doable, which is great as investing is a key step towards financial security.

Expand full comment

Pleased the principle has sunk in.

Expand full comment

This article was an interesting read! I really enjoyed how you simplified the relationship between risk and return, especially in showing how higher risk can lead to higher potential rewards but also greater losses. This made me evaluate my own risk tolerance when considering different types of investments.

Expand full comment

Both Vanguard and Schwab have tools to match up your risk tolerance with recommended stock and fixed income percentage allocations

Expand full comment

Do you have an opinion on cryptocurrency investments like bitcoin which are likely considered high risk?

Expand full comment

Yes, they are high risk. We don’t have enough good information yet. Give it time.

Expand full comment

I really like how you break down the importance of simplifying personal finance and making stock investing approachable. The advice to avoid active management and focus on index funds is really practical and it makes the idea of investing feel less overwhelming.

Expand full comment

Sweet. Mission accomplished!!

Expand full comment

Doing some light reading before class and catching up on articles. I really like how you opened this article with "money should be uncomplicated." I think (at least for me) until your class it was never something that had been talked about in my education years and I think it is giving me the opportunity to learn more about my financial health, investing, etc.

Expand full comment

I don't always hit the mark, but I want money to be uncomplicated to readers.

Expand full comment

After going through it again, I really liked how the game reflected real-life scenarios that most, if not all, of us will be experiencing in the future. It's incredibly important to plan ahead versus planning in the moment, especially when it comes to finance. I feel that has been something that has definitely been highlighted for me more through our use of MaxiFi, which has been another incredibly useful tool. I liked the idea of using the game as well to calculate risks as it's a fun way to approach real-life situations and still provide useful knowledge.

Expand full comment

If, a few months from now, you are thinking about these principles then you are taking away a lot. Pleased to hear about the impact.

Expand full comment

This was a really interesting read. I believe many people are a bit afraid of getting involved in the stock market because it is daunting. This is unfortunate and many people do delegate their finances to a Wealth Manager because of this. My opinion is that their can be a balance of taking advice from a wealth manager while also managing some of your own savings and using them effectively. Being tied to one person is never good and diversifying ones wealth is important, but diversifying it among people can also be a strong tool to grow wealth.

Expand full comment

All the guidance you need is a brokerage account and/or a self managed 401k and Malkiel’s “A Random Walk Down Wall Street”

Expand full comment